Hi Statalist,
I would like to estimate a complementary loglog model with induvidual effects using Stata's xtcloglog command.
My dependent variabel is binary with rare events and I have a panel structure with small T and large N, so everything is fine for this kind of model.
I am now struggeling whether to use the pa (population averaged) or re (random effects) option for accounting for individual effects.
The general differences of thes two models are described e.g. here:
https://www.stata.com/support/faqs/s...tion-averaged/
and in more detail here:
http://journals.sfu.ca/llcs/index.ph...ewFile/249/238
The problem ist that I am interested in the marginal effects of a count variable (number of patents applied) on the dependent variable (the probability of bankruptcy of a firm) and that the results are very different for the pa and re model.
The second source I posted says (on page 155-156) that because of the non-llinearity of the assumed distribution the estimated coefficients differ and how they differ. However they also say that standard errors should vary proportionally and thus no serious effects on significant tests are to be expected. But in my case only one model delivers statistical significant results.
I estimate the marginal effects using the margins command at different values of my explanatory variable (say 0, 1 or 5 patents) and the atmeans option for the controls. I suppose no more information about my data is needed to understand the problem but I can offer later.
So beside the effects that it is obviously relevant to select the correct option (re or pa) for the research question, why do the marginal effects for point-estimates and standard errors differ quite substatially?
Thanks and best regards
Tim
Related Posts with xtcloglog population averaged vs. random effects
Use past quarter average of data to regress with next quarter data.Hello all, I am a newbie to STATA and struggling with a peculiar problem. Hoping for some insight f…
Dropping variables in the batch structureMy dataset contains ~4000 variables from a survey that collected data on upto 10 members from the sa…
-mimrgns- and -marginsplot-The help file for mimrgns states that while "[i]n principle, marginsplot works after mimrgns […], th…
Confusion about how to keep one row of data for each student with the most number of classes taken in a programI am using Stata 15.1 for Windows. I would like to keep a certain student in the program that he co…
problems with moving average - panel dataHi everyone, I am using Italian administrative longitudinal data for 10 years. Since I would like to…
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
0 Response to xtcloglog population averaged vs. random effects
Post a Comment