Several times recently, I've noticed new questions posted as followups on old (sometime quite old) threads. A recent example would be this .
While this practice reflects that the questioner has made a laudable effort to search for relevant material, I (and perhaps others) find this confusing and not useful. (On the humorous side, I've more than once spent 30 min. writing a response to a posting early in the thread only to discover that the next page has the rest of the thread with the *new* question <grin>.)
I wonder if such followers to old threads are perhaps responding to something in the FAQ? I'd find it more useful to encourage people to make a new posting but include a link to any previous relevant thread. I'd prefer this even when the new question is nearly identical, e.g. "I have this problem that I tried to solved per ThisOldLink, but I'm running into difficulties, ... ."
Any reaction to this, including ideas of how to prompt the link-posting approach, if you think it preferable?
Related Posts with Meta comment re new questions posted as followups to old threads
Negative Predicted MarginsHello everyone, I hope someone would be able to help me. I am trying to predict the probability to…
Clustered Standard Errors in Stata replication in MatlabHi, I am replicating a paper in Matlab that uses Stata. Problem setup: paper uses, for example, -reg…
robvar to excelAny idea on how I can get the results of robvar command to excel? …
Potential Bug in -ivprobit, twostep-?Hello all, -ivprobit, twostep- is an application of the control function approach to the probit mod…
Adding upword/downword mobility in DRMI am learning diagonal reference model using DRM package in STATA. I noticed many papers add upward/…
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
0 Response to Meta comment re new questions posted as followups to old threads
Post a Comment