Hi,

1. I want to estimate my risk measures using bi-variate diagonal GARCH (1,1) model (DVECH) for each of my 360 panels (IDs) in the data(for a time period of 20 years). when I simply run my code, the error I get is that "sample may not include multiple panels". Could someone help me devise foreach code to extract correlation coefficient between X and Y variable, Variance or standard deviation of the Y variable, Variance or standard deviation of the X variable, t stat and p values.

The regression syntax I am using is as:

mgarch dvech (Y=L.Y) (X=L.X), arch(1) garch(1)

where Y is the dependant variable, L.Y is the lagged Y variable at (t-1), X is the independent variable.

Please see my data example below for just two panels IDs(275 and 276) posted here:

Code:
* Example generated by -dataex-. To install: ssc install dataex
clear
input long ID float(Date X Y)
275 17532   -.9448536    .8354189
275 17533    .3487111   -.2693492
275 17534    .2836161  -.17842436
275 17535           .           0
275 17538    1.656796           .
275 17539    .9286202  -.08710092
275 17540  -1.8091848  -.04588305
275 17541   1.6367277   .16509503
275 17542           .           0
275 17545     2.59634           .
275 17546    1.678565   -.0810245
275 17547   1.0624355    .4417567
275 17548   -2.242841  -.13226286
275 17549           .           0
275 17552    6.591204           .
275 17553  -1.0402253    3.274396
275 17554  -2.8957386    -.458727
275 17555  -1.4676168   -.3175855
275 17556           .           0
275 17559   2.3655958           .
275 17560   .09141315   -.3981869
275 17561   .57441044   -.1596823
275 17562   1.0667937  .009047816
275 17563           .           0
275 17566  -1.7750583           .
275 17567   1.4845915  .074129224
275 17568           0   .19125396
275 17569           0   .02732165
275 17570           .           0
275 17573    2.484294           .
275 17574   -.4080752   -.3319641
275 17575    .7379941  -.29444113
275 17576   -3.068964   -.3005825
275 17577           .           0
275 17580   -.7636237           .
275 17581    .4831726   -.3440623
275 17582    .7934458   .02211948
275 17583  -2.0359843  -.08973708
275 17584           .           0
275 17587   1.3930135           .
275 17588  -1.3764292  -.03779463
275 17589  -2.0453684  -.07851576
275 17590    .9485728   .02572221
275 17591           .           0
275 17594   1.9457484           .
275 17595 -.017554902  -.13483116
275 17596    .2816869  -.07304642
275 17597  -1.1848292  -.07768305
275 17598           .           0
275 17601    .5061342           .
275 17602  -1.2829027   -.3825753
275 17603  -1.8511173    -.326667
275 17604    2.428849   .18069623
275 17605           .           0
275 17608   1.0206416           .
275 17609  -2.3306415  -.11481378
275 17610   -.5284565  .012798377
275 17611           0  .014203067
275 17612           .           0
275 17615  -1.4381084           .
275 17616   -3.162646   -.2389299
275 17617  -1.1833931   .01078685
275 17618   .16642608  -.13291514
275 17619           .           0
275 17622    .7881719           .
275 17623  -1.9291533   -.6465864
275 17624   -2.484611   -.4927806
275 17625   -.4476654    .0501497
275 17626           .           0
275 17629  -1.0812626           .
275 17630    .2128137   -.4863795
275 17631    .7718029   -.3550645
275 17632  -2.5250444  -.18530308
275 17633           .           0
275 17636   1.9678795           .
275 17637   1.4971073   .09815712
275 17638   -.5609957    .0976398
275 17639  -1.4524742  -.06738571
275 17640           .           0
275 17643  -1.5427467           .
275 17644  -.07093139    1.545077
275 17645   -.8000664    .7919154
275 17646   1.2043766   .24864738
275 17647           .           0
275 17650   -.8486731           .
275 17651   -.3858811   -.1931482
275 17652           0   .01122949
275 17653   -.9671556    .1462957
275 17654           .           0
275 17657  -.41946185           .
275 17658  -.11834846    .4144604
275 17659    .7723355    .7863739
275 17660   2.2498853   .35206985
275 17661           .           0
275 17664    .3849867           .
275 17665   -.4651551 -.067269385
275 17666    .8010302   .05592031
275 17667   -.5863638   .10466933
275 17668           .           0
275 17671   -1.714908           .
275 17672   .55663955  -.02399113
275 17673   -.5582111  -.19157113
275 17674   1.2003723   .21305996
275 17675           .           0
275 17678   1.8554692           .
275 17679   .45745665      .64939
275 17680  -.12183766    .7578576
275 17681   .53087777   .10868005
275 17682           .           0
275 17685  -.07326257           .
275 17686   1.0590341  -.26588959
275 17687      .35715   -.3316403
275 17688    .1465411  -.07622816
275 17689           .           0
275 17692    2.624693           .
275 17693   1.6282976   .08328944
275 17694   -.9891568   -.3005187
275 17695    .7715387   .09954578
275 17696           .           0
275 17699  -2.2379537           .
275 17700   -.4555624   -.3852659
275 17701   .14622067  -.08326889
275 17702   1.7126575    .3337774
275 17703           .           0
275 17706   .52168447           .
275 17707 -.016833052    -.360022
275 17708  -1.4465773    .3252652
275 17709  -1.0467112  -.03505685
275 17710           .           0
275 17713   1.0990441           .
275 17714    1.334379  -.11756666
275 17715  -1.3395193   .10773988
275 17716   1.2523624   .20052333
275 17717           .           0
275 17720   -.2701383           .
275 17721   1.4375293   1.0624845
275 17722  -1.7240967    .0996057
275 17723    .9814016   .06832132
275 17724           .           0
275 17727   .05752651           .
275 17728   1.0759283   1.2098705
275 17729   1.0457535    .8387258
275 17730   -.8885576   .09181806
275 17731           .           0
275 17734   -1.840747           .
275 17735    .9189287   -.2369358
275 17736  -1.7101812   -.3988784
275 17737   -.5019524 -.012656693
275 17738           .           0
275 17741    -.450145           .
275 17742     1.74288    .4152934
275 17743   -1.361951   .22918233
275 17744   -.3784299  .036926772
275 17745           .           0
275 17748    .7786454           .
275 17749   -.8225358    .6326553
275 17750    .3362251   .09695192
275 17751     2.62957    .2126996
275 17752           .           0
275 17755   1.3273808           .
275 17756   -.9506874    .6310061
275 17757   -.8665434    .3440818
275 17758  .011449438  -.04084237
275 17759           .           0
275 17762   -.6029612           .
275 17763   2.0009193     .676532
275 17764  -1.0074242    .4899583
275 17765    .4939459     .163318
275 17766           .           0
275 17769    .4387149           .
275 17770   1.6924874    .3743745
275 17771   -.3183445    -.420342
275 17772   -.4176282 -.010667897
275 17773           .           0
275 17776   1.5126754           .
275 17777  -1.3462456    .9574438
275 17778      1.4175    .4151205
275 17779   2.3630495   .19571374
275 17780           .           0
275 17783   -5.192647           .
275 17784     .787276   .30941185
275 17785   1.5859063    .8979475
275 17786   4.1234207    .4249836
275 17787           .           0
275 17790    2.649753           .
275 17791   1.0324059    3.144228
275 17792   1.0113052  -1.1764535
275 17793    .2163054   .06195149
275 17794           .           0
275 17797   .27457067           .
275 17798    2.593637    .8793958
275 17799   .24451683    .6621457
275 17800   1.4845705   .06394596
275 17801           .           0
275 17804   1.3420187           .
275 17805           0 .0021264986
275 17806   -.9225485   .07488141
275 17807   .44253105    .0693523
275 17808           .           0
275 17811    8.550269           .
275 17812  -.10918797    3.620046
275 17813    5.682075    1.683814
275 17814   -4.500806 -.024856167
275 17815           .           0
275 17818   -4.796797           .
275 17819   -4.262467  -3.0210874
275 17820    3.003715   1.1346748
275 17821    3.437421    .4610553
275 17822           .           0
275 17825   -4.481159           .
275 17826     3.58992  -.06506504
275 17827    5.668676     2.29232
275 17828    7.681322    .5397015
275 17829           .           0
275 17832   11.532278           .
275 17833  -4.6320586   .27511767
275 17834    5.731647   -.9557837
275 17835   -8.629296    -.477014
275 17836           .           0
275 17839   -5.878052           .
275 17840   1.9197185   -.6787698
275 17841   -4.004157   -.5425225
275 17842    4.790688    .4592072
275 17843           .           0
275 17846     .904058           .
275 17847   4.0181484    2.674548
275 17848   2.0851493    1.557288
275 17849   2.8203266   .35117126
275 17850           .           0
275 17853    1.912763           .
275 17854    .8629184    .4985007
275 17855     2.79079    .3115564
275 17856   3.5591354    .3217009
275 17857           .           0
275 17860   -.3935625           .
275 17861    -5.14361  -.26080194
275 17862  -2.1745372   .31906235
275 17863   -2.106215  -.09433806
275 17864           .           0
275 17867    4.057175           .
275 17868    1.773407   1.5954512
275 17869   1.8641368  -.18450505
275 17870   -.7844057  -.02482805
275 17871           .           0
275 17874   -.7754063           .
275 17875   -7.718072  -.52155423
275 17876  -4.3969555  -.35110685
275 17877   -.9990728  -.09066255
275 17878           .           0
275 17881   -.5766259           .
275 17882   -2.892514  -.21423855
275 17883    1.621788   .12884219
275 17884   -.1113434  -.14128058
275 17885           .           0
275 17888   1.8014857           .
275 17889    .9284344  -.20125595
275 17890           0   .06472899
275 17891   -3.250345 -.008247561
275 17892           .           0
275 17895 .0008978591           .
275 17896  -2.5990536   -.1691266
275 17897           0  -.05741507
276 17532    1.635493    .8354189
276 17533   -1.471723   -.2693492
276 17534           0  -.17842436
276 17535           .           0
276 17538    -.871711           .
276 17539           0  -.08710092
276 17540   1.5456324  -.04588305
276 17541           0   .16509503
276 17542           .           0
276 17545    1.551087           .
276 17546    -2.31708   -.0810245
276 17547   -19.10259    .4417567
276 17548           0  -.13226286
276 17549           .           0
276 17552   -9.462498           .
276 17553    4.197288    3.274396
276 17554  -1.8090326    -.458727
276 17555           0   -.3175855
276 17556           .           0
276 17559   3.1783845           .
276 17560   -1.410829   -.3981869
276 17561  -.59593374   -.1596823
276 17562           0  .009047816
276 17563           .           0
276 17566   -7.737052           .
276 17567   -.0888175  .074129224
276 17568   -6.291576   .19125396
276 17569           0   .02732165
276 17570           .           0
276 17573   3.4900906           .
276 17574   -6.061938   -.3319641
276 17575  -12.494024  -.29444113
276 17576           0   -.3005825
276 17577           .           0
276 17580   -5.204611           .
276 17581  -13.437892   -.3440623
276 17582   13.239464   .02211948
276 17583           0  -.08973708
276 17584           .           0
276 17587    -4.83119           .
276 17588  -4.6089635  -.03779463
276 17589   3.7785664  -.07851576
276 17590           0   .02572221
276 17591           .           0
276 17594   -3.428463           .
276 17595   -3.530055  -.13483116
276 17596   -1.370222  -.07304642
276 17597           0  -.07768305
276 17598           .           0
276 17601  -11.636923           .
276 17602  -17.389702   -.3825753
276 17603  -18.345716    -.326667
276 17604           0   .18069623
276 17605           .           0
276 17608   2.4213905           .
276 17609     3.26327  -.11481378
276 17610           0  .012798377
276 17611           0  .014203067
276 17612           .           0
276 17615   -4.535011           .
276 17616   -12.42974   -.2389299
276 17617   15.186446   .01078685
276 17618           0  -.13291514
276 17619           .           0
276 17622     1.33363           .
276 17623  -1.9559397   -.6465864
276 17624   3.4256854   -.4927806
276 17625           0    .0501497
276 17626           .           0
276 17629  -11.614422           .
276 17630   -4.794767   -.4863795
276 17631    2.332233   -.3550645
276 17632           0  -.18530308
276 17633           .           0
276 17636   -4.371339           .
276 17637     .770042   .09815712
276 17638    .7922998    .0976398
276 17639           0  -.06738571
276 17640           .           0
276 17643    .7293228           .
276 17644    1.660068    1.545077
276 17645  -1.0115426    .7919154
276 17646           0   .24864738
276 17647           .           0
276 17650    30.45607           .
276 17651    1.897267   -.1931482
276 17652           0   .01122949
276 17653           0    .1462957
276 17654           .           0
276 17657    5.494571           .
276 17658    2.582631    .4144604
276 17659     .830285    .7863739
276 17660           0   .35206985
276 17661           .           0
276 17664    6.690775           .
276 17665    6.950309 -.067269385
276 17666    7.396179   .05592031
276 17667           0   .10466933
276 17668           .           0
276 17671    -7.63819           .
276 17672   -6.051295  -.02399113
276 17673    3.028843  -.19157113
276 17674           0   .21305996
276 17675           .           0
276 17678    .9714295           .
276 17679  -1.6027133      .64939
276 17680    5.937746    .7578576
276 17681           0   .10868005
276 17682           .           0
276 17685    8.544799           .
276 17686   -2.945718  -.26588959
276 17687  -.03857173   -.3316403
276 17688           0  -.07622816
276 17689           .           0
276 17692   -2.600786           .
276 17693    .6139032   .08328944
276 17694   1.6856712   -.3005187
276 17695           0   .09954578
276 17696           .           0
276 17699    2.087778           .
276 17700    1.319442   -.3852659
276 17701   1.3170284  -.08326889
276 17702           0    .3337774
276 17703           .           0
276 17706   1.3789568           .
276 17707   -5.528686    -.360022
276 17708           0    .3252652
276 17709           0  -.03505685
276 17710           .           0
276 17713           0           .
276 17714  -1.3029145  -.11756666
276 17715   1.2934916   .10773988
276 17716           0   .20052333
276 17717           .           0
276 17720    8.565106           .
276 17721   1.1018476   1.0624845
276 17722  .006335855    .0996057
276 17723           0   .06832132
276 17724           .           0
276 17727   -5.383254           .
276 17728    3.698886   1.2098705
276 17729   13.676517    .8387258
276 17730           0   .09181806
276 17731           .           0
276 17734    5.082239           .
276 17735           0   -.2369358
276 17736  -2.6525104   -.3988784
276 17737           0 -.012656693
276 17738           .           0
276 17741   -.5998918           .
276 17742   10.465086    .4152934
276 17743   -3.024452   .22918233
276 17744           0  .036926772
276 17745           .           0
276 17748   4.2909007           .
276 17749     3.36493    .6326553
276 17750   -.8218333   .09695192
276 17751           0    .2126996
276 17752           .           0
276 17755    7.924467           .
276 17756    6.292953    .6310061
276 17757     7.13474    .3440818
276 17758           0  -.04084237
276 17759           .           0
276 17762    4.456162           .
276 17763    8.219277     .676532
276 17764   .04869774    .4899583
276 17765           0     .163318
276 17766           .           0
276 17769   1.8572234           .
276 17770   .17269987    .3743745
276 17771  -1.4594604    -.420342
276 17772           0 -.010667897
276 17773           .           0
276 17776   -6.486739           .
276 17777   .24245247    .9574438
276 17778  -14.381198    .4151205
276 17779           0   .19571374
276 17780           .           0
276 17783  -1.1779838           .
276 17784   1.1361294   .30941185
276 17785   -1.201011    .8979475
276 17786           0    .4249836
276 17787           .           0
276 17790   11.440876           .
276 17791    3.396565    3.144228
276 17792    .4810865  -1.1764535
276 17793           0   .06195149
276 17794           .           0
276 17797  -1.0431293           .
276 17798    .7270016    .8793958
276 17799    3.287153    .6621457
276 17800           0   .06394596
276 17801           .           0
276 17804           0           .
276 17805           0 .0021264986
276 17806           0   .07488141
276 17807           0    .0693523
276 17808           .           0
276 17811   -6.233808           .
276 17812   10.348805    3.620046
276 17813    .5770051    1.683814
276 17814           0 -.024856167
276 17815           .           0
276 17818   -.7836846           .
276 17819   -4.708588  -3.0210874
276 17820    1.363078   1.1346748
276 17821           0    .4610553
276 17822           .           0
276 17825    4.240919           .
276 17826    3.610716  -.06506504
276 17827    19.56696     2.29232
276 17828           0    .5397015
276 17829           .           0
276 17832    .6601269           .
276 17833   -3.425278   .27511767
276 17834    5.184638   -.9557837
276 17835           0    -.477014
276 17836           .           0
276 17839   1.1907704           .
276 17840   -3.684428   -.6787698
276 17841    5.196092   -.5425225
276 17842           0    .4592072
276 17843           .           0
276 17846   -18.75826           .
276 17847   -2.741206    2.674548
276 17848   10.536908    1.557288
276 17849           0   .35117126
276 17850           .           0
276 17853   4.2906303           .
276 17854    9.635596    .4985007
276 17855    .4515028    .3115564
276 17856           0    .3217009
276 17857           .           0
276 17860    7.678648           .
276 17861  -2.0375218  -.26080194
276 17862  -.57947344   .31906235
276 17863           0  -.09433806
276 17864           .           0
276 17867   3.0766544           .
276 17868    3.938889   1.5954512
276 17869   -1.958521  -.18450505
276 17870           0  -.02482805
276 17871           .           0
276 17874           0           .
276 17875   -.8067458  -.52155423
276 17876  -1.3497015  -.35110685
276 17877           0  -.09066255
276 17878           .           0
276 17881   1.0332724           .
276 17882   1.4363856  -.21423855
276 17883   -.5722924   .12884219
276 17884           0  -.14128058
276 17885           .           0
276 17888   -.8590128           .
276 17889   1.6446818  -.20125595
276 17890    1.536159   .06472899
276 17891           0 -.008247561
276 17892           .           0
276 17895    .6297305           .
276 17896  -1.9363302   -.1691266
276 17897           0  -.05741507
end
format %td Date
label values ID ID
label def ID 275 "OCBC SP Equity", modify
label def ID 276 "ODIN EY Equity", modify

2. My Y variable data is not normally distributed, what techniques I shall consider to normalize it for GARCH modelling? The assumption is that both the Y and X variable follow a bi-variate normal distribution.

Regards